Right or Wrong Betting – Etiquette at the Craps Table

Question: Not too long ago I was playing craps at an almost full table and most of us were betting the pass line along with the shooter. But there was this one guy who was betting wrong and hoping that the shooter would lose.

The worst part of it was he was really loud and annoying about it. On every roll he yelled, “Come on seven!” and when seven hit, he screamed, celebrated, and even taunted the rest of us who had just lost our bets. I wanted to hit him! What can be done about guys like this?

The short answer is – not much.

For many people, the appeal of craps is the social aspect of the game. Nearly everyone plays together on the pass line/come line, so when the shooter hit a taxpoint and wins, everyone at the table wins and celebrates together. In craps parlance, this is called betting “right”.

However, not everyone is there for the fun and it's hard to blame someone when they choose to bet against the shooter and play the don't pass/don't come; after all, it does have a slightly lower casino edge. While these people may not exactly be the most fun in the world, betting “wrong” like this is perfectly legal and he has the same right as you do to get excited when he wins.

That being said, your wrong bettor could have been more polite. Most wrong bettors just want to win, not spoil the other players' good time, so they quietly play their game and give a little silent cheer when they win, but nothing more. Your guy could learn from them.

Question: I thought I understood the tax reporting rules at casinos, but after what happened last week I'm completely lost. I was playing blackjack while my friend was on the Caribbean Stud table. We both had great nights, I finished almost $1,500 up, while my buddy hit a straight flush and won about $1,000. What confused me is that my friend had to sign a tax reporting form for his win, while I cashed out without anyone saying anything? Why?

The IRS requires casinos to report wins for taxation purposes only in the event of one-time jackpot wins, not on all winning players in the casino. Of course, it is important to remember that the IRS requires you to pay taxes on all net casino winnings, no matter whether the casino reports the win or not.

For table games that carry high-odds payouts or jackpots like Caribbean Stud, casinos are required to report any win where the odds are higher than 300-1 and the winning amount is more than $600, which is why your friend had to sign the tax form. But since blackjack is generally an even-money game, you could win as much as possible and it wouldn't be reported.

Slot machines carry a slighter higher minimum threshold for reporting, $1,200. And remember, that is only if you win that amount on a single spin; if you win more than that through a series of small wins then you can walk away without having to sign everything. The only exception is if you are playing a slot tournament, then any win over $600 is reported.

About The Author

Journalist and author John Grochowski is one of the foremost experts on casinos in America. He writes a syndicated weekly gambling newspaper column and he is a frequent contributor to gambling magazines, websites, and radio programs. His books include the best-sellers The Slot Machine Answer Book and The Casino Answer Book.

  • "Modern video keno can trace its roots all the way back to ancient China, where a lottery-style game called 'white dove' was used to finance the army during times of war and hardship."

  • "Never take a cash advance from your credit card in a casino. The fees charged by the casino are outrageous, and don't include the additional fee that your credit card company will charge you."

  • "Playing at a full roulette table is far better than playing at an empty one because it reduces the number of spins you see per hour while qualifying you for better comps through longer play."

  • "Speed is good for the casino but bad for you. The more times you play per hour, the more the house edge compounds and makes it more likely that you will lose overall."

  • "The long run, so to speak, is the expected amount that you would win or lose if you played the game long enough to equal an average result. This is expressed as the EV, or expected value."